Question:
Battle of the drummers?
Nooo
2012-05-30 23:08:07 UTC
Ok, so this is just like Battle of the Bands; but with drummers, I'm going to do 14 matchups, pick which drummer you like better.
I'll specify which bands they're from and if you don't know them or hate them both, just put N/A.

1. Christoph Schneider (Rammstein) vs. Joey Jordison (Slipknot)

2. Danny Carey (Tool) vs. Mike Portnoy (Dream Theater)

3. Adam Carson (AFI) vs. John Otto (Limp Bizkit)

4. Shannon Leto (30 Seconds to Mars) vs. Travis Barker (Blink 182)

5. Dave Grohl (Nirvana) vs. Brad Wilk (RATM)

6. Keith Moon (The Who) vs. Peter Criss (KISS)

7. Bill Ward (Black Sabbath) vs. Dave Lombardo (Slayer)

8. Tre Cool (Green Day) vs. Phil Selway (Radiohead)

9.John Densmore (the Doors) vs. Ringo Starr (The Beatles)

10. Tommy Lee (Motley Crue) vs.Steven Adler (G'n'R)

11. Brann Dailor (Mastodon) vs. Tomas Haake (Meshuggah)

12. Neil Peart (Rush) vs. Ian Paice (Deep Purple)

13. John Bonham (Led Zeppelin) vs. Roger Taylor (Queen)

14. Josh Freese (A Perfect Circle) vs. Jon Theodore (Mars Volta)

...aaaaand done!
Eight answers:
?
2012-05-30 23:15:59 UTC
**** yeah, my favorite subject!



1. Chrisoph Schnieder (Although Joey Jordison is an animal)



2. Mike Portnoy (Very tough matchup, but I've liked Dream Theater longer)



3. Adam Carson (Don't know either, but AFI is pretty good)



4. Channon Leto (Travis Barker is over rated)



5. Dave Grohl (He's great with Tenacious D!)



6. KIETH MOON! (One of the 3 greatest drummers of all time)



7. Dave Lombardo (Both are legends, but Slayer is better)



8. Tre' Cool! (I named my dog after him! And I've met him 4 times, he's insane)



9. John Densmore (Ringo Starr is amazing, but I personally think John showed his drumming skills better)



10. Tommy Lee (MOTLEY CRUE!!!!)



11. Brann Dailor (TOUGH matchup, Thomas is probably better. But I know Brann personally, and he is one hell of a guy, and a drummer of course!)



12. Neil Peart (Tough matchup aswell, I love Deep Purple)



13. JOHN BONHAM (Arguably the best drummer of all time)



14. Jon Theodore (Although I think Thomas Pridgen was better for The Mars Volta)





Great question! :D
2012-05-30 23:58:00 UTC
1. Cristoph Schneider

2. Mike Portnoy

3. Adam Carson

4. Travis Barker, I guess

5. Dave Grohl

6. Keith Moon

7. Dave Lombardo

8. Tre Cool

9. Ringo Starr, he has a nice simple style

10. Steven Adler

11. Tomas Haake

12. Neil Peart

13. John Bonham

14. Josh Freese
Mohak
2012-05-30 23:37:35 UTC
1.Christoph. Joey is Epic, Christoph just happens to be better.

2.Portnoy, fo sho. *insert random niqqa here*. i really LOVE Tool's drums, but you just can't compare it to Portnoy's style.

3. N/A. Haven't listened to much of either to comment.

4. Refer 3

5. Brad, all the way.

6. Keith Moon. Hands down.

7. i'll go with Bill here. although i enjoy Dave smashing the living sh!t out of those drums, i like Bill's stuff more.

8. Phil.

9. Ringo. i dunno why people hate him. he's a good drummer.

10. Steven.

11, Tomas Haake. No contest. My favourite metal drummer.

12. Neil Peart. This was difficult.

13. Bonham. one of the best drummers. Ever.

14. Jon.
@DaevMustien
2012-05-30 23:31:29 UTC
I'm not totally familiar with all of these drummers



1.Jordison (But only vaguely & barely familiar w/ Rammstein)

2.Portnoy

3.AFI

4.Tough one, but I'll go with Barker

5.Grohl

6.Keith Moon no contest

7.Lombardo

8.Tre Cool

9.The Doors guy

10.Tommy Lee

11.Brann Dailor (Not really familiar w/ Meshuggahs music but cmon, Dailor is a BEAST)

12.Peart

13.Bonham EASY

14.Not familiar with either band
Cherry2000
2012-05-30 23:24:35 UTC
1. Christoph Schneider (Rammstein)

2. Danny Carey (Tool)

3. Adam Carson (AFI)

4. Travis Barker (Blink 182)

5. Brad Wilk (RATM)

6. Keith Moon (The Who)

7. Bill Ward (Black Sabbath)

8. Tre Cool (Green Day)

9.John Densmore (the Doors)

10. Tommy Lee (Motley Crue)

11. Brann Dailor (Mastodon)

12. Neil Peart (Rush)

13. John Bonham (Led Zeppelin)

14. Josh Freese (A Perfect Circle)
zubb999
2012-05-30 23:23:17 UTC
1) I prefer Christoph, but Joey is the better drummer (obvioisly).

2) PORTNOY!!! He wins any drum battle, period.

3) N/A

4) Travis is so overglorified! I hate it. Shannon wins this one.

5) Dave Grohl is a genius! Enough said.

6) Keith Moon.

7) N/A

8) Green Day has easy@$$ drum parts. It's Phil.

9) John. The Doors always improvised. The Beatles couldn't hope to do that (at least Ringo couldn't).

10) N/A

11) N/A

12) Neil Pert. No questions asked, no reason needed.

13) John

14) N/A
2012-05-30 23:12:57 UTC
1) Christoph

2) Danny Carey

3) Adam Carson

4) Travis Barker

5) Dave Grohl

6) Keith Moon

7) Dave Lombardo.

8) Tre Cool

9) John Densmore

10) Tommy Lee

11) Tomas Haake

12) Neil Peart

13) John Bonham

14) Josh Freese
icefox94
2012-05-30 23:11:23 UTC
Joey Jordison



Mike Portnoy



Adam Carson



Travis Barker



Dave Grohl



I want to say Peter Criss because i'm a huge Kiss fan but Keith Moon is probably a better player



Bill WArd



Tre Cool



Ringo Starr



Damn thats a really hard one idk maybe Tommy Lee by alittle



Brann Dailor



Neil Peart



Roger Taylor



Jon Theodore


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...