Nirvana & Stone Temple Pilots???!?

Question

Many people think these two bands sound alot a like and get STP's music mixed up and call it Nirvana's. Like the songs Plush, and Creep. Whats your oppinion??

Answer 1

nothing will ever come close to nirvana



stone temple pilots are good

but personally i dont think they sound like nirvana at all



they arent grunge and the singers voice sounds more like the pearl jam guys voice not kurt cobain



i dont think anyone will ever sound like kurt



his voice was amazing and so distinct.



actually i think that they sound more like pearl jam than anything.



but that was in the some plush



in creep



well OMG YA



i just got it to listen to it



and i always thought that was a nirvana song.



so ya they sound like nirvana alot in that song.



idk about the other ones tho.



thanks for clarifying that for me

Answer 2

#1 ALWAYS Nirvana 2, Pearl Jam 3 Stone Temple Pilots 4 Alice in Chains 5 Soundgarden

Answer 3

I could see someone not paying attention and being slightly tone deaf making that type of claim, but not anyone else. I don't like nirvana. I did when they first came out, but soon after I got sick of them. I liked stp for a long time. I still enjoy some of stp's songs. I would be very hard pressed to find a nirvana song to listen to.

Answer 4

I've been hearing comparisons between Nirvana and STP a lot lately...frankly I never thought they sounded even remotely alike. STP and Pearl Jam, I can certainly see a resemblance there. I used to get "Even Flow" and "Plush" mixed up when they first came out.

Answer 5

no freakin way! They are completely different! If you listen to old stp their music progressions move around a heck of a lot more then Nirvana's, which based theirs on just a couple of note progressions. No they sound totally different

Answer 6

I believe that due to their similar grunge upbringing and the fact that theyre both part of the seattle grunge movement (along with pearl jam) that they do sound similar. Learn some Nirvana on Base nick

Answer 7

Nope not at all man. Now listen to Seether's Shaun Morgan and he sounds like Kurt, Seether has done some covers of Nirvana and it is spooky.

Answer 8

I think that STP and Soundgarden sound more alike and would be easily confused by people that aren't familiar with them.

With Nirvana, No.

Answer 9

They sound nothing alike. Completely different.

Answer 10

These bands do not sound alike at all...

Answer 11

I'm gonna have to go with Mariebear on this one.

Answer 12

they are both amazing.

Answer 13

no way!

not even close!