John Bonham or Neil Pert?

Question

For me its John Bonham without even having to think about it.

BQ Favorite Zep Songs
BQ2 Favorite Rush Songs

Answer 1

John Bonham... i agree, i didnt really have to think. I mean u automatically know its him when u hear the drums... its very unique - with his insane and almost impossible rythym patterns.



BQ: Kashmir, Dazed and Confused, Communication Breakdown, Heartbreaker, The Rover

BQ2: Working Man, Red barchetta, YYZ, The Big Money, Tom Sawyer



both great bands!! bonham was just a way better drummer though :)

Answer 2

Peart by a long shot. Bonham isn't a bad drummer by any means, but even my massive Zep fan best friend admits that Bonham's drumlines sound the same in every Zeppelin song, give or take a few acoustic numbers and such (like Going to California or even Boogie with Stu). just watching Rush live you realize how amazingly proficient Peart is as a percussionist, he can play every style imaginable. Same with Bill Bruford, Billy Cobham, Tony Williams, George Hurley, D.J. Bonebrake.



BQ: No Quarter, How Many More Times, Down by the Seaside, Gallows Pole, In the Light, Hots on for Nowhere

BQ2: Working Man, 2112, Passage to Bangkok, New World Man, Cygnus X-1: Book II, YYZ, Red Sector A

Answer 3

As an accomplished musician and percussionist, Peart by miles and miles.



As a pure Rock Drummer, Bonham by a little bit.



BQ: In The Evening



BQ2: Distant Early Warning

Answer 4

Neil Pert is okay. Bonham replaced into fantastic, and he did double bass with basically one bass drum. He additionally stored great rhythm and replaced into average a great guy or woman. yet Keith Moon had form, replaced into unique, and rather of basically offering a beat that subsidized UP the band, like each drummers do, he provided a beat that emphasised the climate of the band. So Keith, genuinely.

Answer 5

Neil Pert, though they are both world class drummers, Neil Pert beats Bonham. Skillwise, his rhythms, and technicality.



I'll limit myself to one song each :]



Zep - Over the Hills and Far Away



Rush - Spirit of Radio



((ºLº))

--(_)--

..J.L..



John Lennon!

Answer 6

John Bonham but it's CLOSE



BA: Carouselambra

BA2: 2112

Answer 7

mee too, bonham is great



BQ:

lemon song

how many more times

hots on for nowhere

in the light

the crunge

friends

BQ2 not a huge rush fan

Answer 8

John Bonham (pbuh). But on what basis are we comparing them? They are not similar in many ways.



BQ: All of them are my favourites.

Since I've Been Loving You, Tea For One, Rain Song.



BQ2: Unsure on the name, but something to do with 'freedom of choice', 'free will', etc.

Answer 9

John Bonham



BQ: Achilles Last Stand, What is and What Should Never Be, Tangerine

BQ2: I was never a fan of them .