Question:
I'm looking for bands that sound like the Decembersists, BUT...?
This Guy!
2010-08-12 23:49:16 UTC
I mean very specific aspects of the Decemberists. I really liked their newest album, and the Crane Wife is probably their second most consistently solid album to me. Most of their stuff seems kind of hit and miss, and my favorite songs always tend to be the ones that tell a story (I know pretty much all of them do, but there'll be a list in a minute so you'll see what I mean). I'm not putting them down, by the way. They're probably one of my favorite bands, because their good stuff is way better than their bad stuff is bad. I'm just not a fan of songs like "We Both Go Down Together" or "July, July!" Anyway, I've checked Pandora and liveplasma, and neither has really helped. And yes, I did try Pandora-ing specific songs that contained all the elements I'm looking for (multi-instrumentation mostly, like accordion, violin, cello, harpsichord, organ, things like that). I always get bands that have really great music, but the vocals sound too neo-swing for my taste. I also realize I'm asking a VERY specific favor here, but based on the following songs, which bands would you recommend to me?

A Cautionary Song
Odalisque
The Island, Come and See, etc...
Most of "Hazards of Love"
Shanty for the Arethusa
Los Angeles, I'm Yours
Chimbley Sweep
I Was Meant for the Stage
The Infanta
The Mariner's Revenge Song
The Tain
My Mother Was a Chinese Trapeze Artist

Ok. I know this question has been asked before on Y!A, but mostly the answers I've seen have been bands that Decemberists fans would like, not necessarily bands that sound like them. Anyways, thanks in advance for your help.
Four answers:
Ryan Selle
2010-08-13 00:14:38 UTC
Tarkio (the singers earlier band)

Harry Chapin

neutral milk hotel

violent femmes



hope those help, the story songs are my favorites too.
Drifter
2010-08-13 00:07:56 UTC
Fleet Foxes

Grizzly Bear

Keane

Sky Sailing

Postal Service

Snow Patrol

The Doves

The Myriad

Neon Horses

My Morning Jacket

Queens Club

The Moody Blues

The Bravery

The Fold

The New Frontiers

Paper Route

The Strokes

Mute Math

Jet

Rooney

Barcelona

Safetysuit

Civil Twillight

The Surrogate

Turn of the Stars

Future of Forestry

Eisley
?
2016-10-16 08:49:26 UTC
At one time I loved journey. Their first 3 albums have been great for me on the time and then they have been given Steve Perry to be their lead singer. the unique journey got here from Santana. Greg Rollie became the singer in Santana, he sang Black Magic lady. That music became a Fleetwood Mac music easily. Neal Schon became additionally a guitarist in Santana and shaped journey with Rollie and Aynsley Dunbar. I loved the 1st Steve Perry album with journey and then they became right into a team of radio friendly ladies. i will call many different bands of the comparable ilk yet this one stands out.
That Shakespeherian Rag
2010-08-13 00:56:33 UTC
Definitely Neutral Milk Hotel. Their second album, In the Aeroplane Over the Sea, is a concept album inspired by an Anne Frank-esque figure.



"Holland, 1945" is your best bet. "Oh Comely," "Ghost," and the title track are great, too. Let me think some, and I'll edit with more.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sCjpbjCH5L0


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...